Reviews of the previous edition The whole point of Treaty ... is to answer all blanket dismissals and the various nagging anxieties that have dogged the subject of a domestic treaty ... While the Prime Minister's assertion [that a nation ... does not make a treaty with itself ] has the beguiling authority of an apparently 'self-evident truth', ... Treaty reveals that hundreds of such localised agreements have already been concluded between Indigenous Australians and all kinds of public and private bodies. ...One of Treaty's great strengths is that it examines closely propositions that appear to lodge issues in 'dead ends', opening up the arguments to new ways and creating a spectrum of options whose progress seems stalled.The resulting optimism is bolstered by evidence of successful agreements made here and overseas with indications of the positive benefits such agreements have effected in the daily lives of the Indigenous signatories.Aside from the persuasions of the research and analysis they present, the quiet, warm and reasonable tone adopted by the authors is likely to charm readers rather than alienate them; confrontation, moral outrage and blaming are conspicuously absent; uncomfortable facts are presented briskly and with cool detachment. Law Society Journal (New South Wales), Vol 43(6), July 2005 A careful and considered work, the result of a three-year research project, rather than a fervent outpouring, Treaty carefully marshals the facts and painstakingly explores the arguments. ... Treaty does away with the false dichotomy that Australia has a choice between symbolic and what the Federal Government has dubbed practical reconciliation . Instead, the authors argue persuasively, we can and should have both, and further, a treaty can serve the dual purpose of being a meaningful gesture and having a material effect. Lorien Kaye, The Age, 18 June 2005